ANALYSIS OF VISUAL REPRESENTATION OF DECOMPOSITION REACTIONS IN NIGERIA SECONDARY SCHOOL CHEMISTRY TEXTBOOK
Abstract
Visual representation in chemistry textbooks play a crucial role in enhancing
student’ understanding of abstract concept, such as decomposition reactions. In
Nigeria, secondary school chemistry education heavily relies on textbooks as primary
instructional materials. However, the accuracy, clarity, and pedagogical quality of
these visual representation remain underexplored, raising concerns about their
effectiveness in supporting student’ conceptual learning. Therefore, this study
analysed the visual representation of decomposition reaction in Nigeria secondary
school chemistry textbooks.
This study used a qualitative content analysis approach to examine the visual
representation of decomposition reaction in Nigeria secondary chemistry textbooks.
Employing a descriptive and interpretive framework based on Johnstone’s triangle
(microscopic, submicroscopic and symbolic levels), the study assessed how visuals
support conceptual understanding. Three widely used and officially approved
textbook were purposively sampled, and a coding framework adapted from Chen et
al. (2020) guided the analysis, focusing on representation levels, functions, text-visual
relationships, and linkages. Data collection involved identifying and categorizing
visuals related to decomposition reactions, while both qualitative and quantitative
methods, including descriptive statistics and bar charts, were used for data analysis.
Validity and reliability were ensured through expert reviews, inter-rater reliability
checks.
Senior secondary school chemistry textbooks mainly employ macro and
symbolic visual representations to illustrate decomposition reactions. New School
Chemistry and Comprehensive Chemistry use only this type, while Essential
Chemistry includes some purely symbolic visuals. In New School Chemistry and
Comprehensive Chemistry, these visuals serve interpretational purposes, whereas in
Essential Chemistry, they are used solely for organizational functions. Across all
three textbooks, the visual representations are entirely aligned with the accompany
text, showing full relevance. Additionally, they all demonstrate complete and
sufficient correlation across multiple level of representations, reflecting strong
integration between visuals and textual content.
The study concluded that senior secondary school chemistry textbooks
consistently depict decomposition reactions using predominantly macroscopic and
symbolic visual representations, with Essential Chemistry also including purely
symbolic visuals and for organization clarity. All three textbooks show complete
alignment between visuals and text and a strong correlation across multiple levels of
representation, promoting coherent and effective learning of decomposition
reactions. The study recommended that textbook authors should consider
incorporating a balanced mix of macroscopic, submicroscopic, and symbolic
representations to provide students with a more comprehensive and multi-level understanding of decomposition reaction
Full-Text Access Notice
In accordance with the NERD Policy on promoting peer-reviewed publication, public access to the full text of a project, thesis or dissertation is restricted for three years, allowing the author and supervisors sufficient time to pursue peer-reviewed publication.
During this period, researchers with legitimate academic or research purposes may request authorisation directly from the author to enable NERD to release the indexed full texts of the work using the form below.